Metal vs. Shingle Roofing in Montana: Which Lasts Longer?

Why Roofing Choice Matters in the Flathead Valley

In northwest Montana, your roof isn’t just a design feature—it’s your home’s first line of defense against snow, ice, wind, and UV exposure. Both metal and asphalt shingles are common across Kalispell, Whitefish, and Columbia Falls, but they perform differently under local conditions.

Sisu Roofing installs and repairs both materials, so here’s an honest breakdown of what to expect from each.

Lifespan and Durability

• Metal Roofing: Properly installed standing-seam metal roofs can last 40–70 years, often outliving the home’s first owners. They’re fire-resistant and hold up well to hail, snow slides, and high winds.
• Shingle Roofing: Modern architectural shingles last 20–30 years when installed with quality underlayment and ventilation. They’re easier to repair if individual areas are damaged by debris or wind.

Winner: Metal roofing wins for longevity—but shingles provide reliable performance at a lower cost.

Cost Comparison

• Shingle Roofing: Typically $8,000–$14,000 for most residential homes in the Flathead Valley.
• Metal Roofing: Usually starts around $16,000–$28,000, depending on roof complexity, panel type, and gauge.

While metal costs more upfront, it can pay off long-term through fewer repairs and potential energy savings.

Weather Resistance

Montana weather doesn’t mess around. Between heavy snowpack and spring thaw, roofs need to withstand everything.

• Metal: Sheds snow easily, reducing the risk of ice dams and leaks. Reflects heat in summer and resists wind uplift exceptionally well.
• Shingles: Handle wind and snow just fine when properly flashed and ventilated, but may require occasional snow removal on steep, shaded sections.

Winner: Both can perform well—but metal handles snow and ice with less maintenance.

Aesthetics and Curb Appeal

• Shingle: Offers traditional appeal with dozens of colors and textures, perfect for craftsman, ranch, and cabin-style homes.
• Metal: Modern, clean look—especially standing seam. Also available in textured or “metal shake” panels that mimic shingles for a classic style.

Many homeowners now mix materials (metal accents on porches or dormers) for a high-end Montana look.

Energy Efficiency and Sustainability

• Metal Roofing: Reflects sunlight, reducing cooling costs in summer and often includes recycled content.
• Malarkey Shingles: The lines we use include upcycled materials and smog-reducing technology, helping clean the air while protecting your home.

Both materials have sustainable options, especially when paired with proper insulation and attic airflow.

So Which Should You Choose?

• Choose Metal if you want a long-term, low-maintenance solution and don’t mind the higher initial cost.
• Choose Shingles if you’re looking for affordability, fast installation, and timeless curb appeal.

Either way, the key is professional installation. Even the best materials won’t perform if the flashing, ventilation, or underlayment are done incorrectly.

Why Homeowners Trust Sisu Roofing

At Sisu Roofing, we specialize in both metal and shingle systems built for Montana’s mountain climate. Whether you’re upgrading for longevity, curb appeal, or energy efficiency, our crew delivers honest recommendations, Malarkey-certified installations, and roofs that stand up to every season in the Flathead Valley.

Ready for a Local Expert Opinion?

Get a free, no-pressure inspection and estimate from Sisu Roofing today.
📞 Call (406) 885-6522 to schedule your appointment.